How to Embed Psychological Safety Into Your Work Culture to Allow for 'Failure' Experimentation?
Failure is often feared, perceived as a threat to reputation and a sign of incompetence. However, it is failure in its very self that plays a critical role in driving innovation and learning within organisations.
Think of all the successful inventions, discoveries and breakthroughs that resulted from multiple trial and error attempts. Steve Jobs was fired from his own company before returning to Apple and launching the revolutionary iPhone. Numerous publishers rejected J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter manuscript before becoming a global phenomenon, and Thomas Edison made over a thousand failed attempts before inventing the light bulb.
Did these failures define their eventual success? No, it was their perseverance and willingness to embrace failure as a stepping stone towards learning and growth that propelled them forward.
As HR leaders, it is crucial to promote a culture where failure is seen as an opportunity for growth rather than a threat. And today, with technology and information providing us with the ability to adapt and innovate faster than ever, creating a safe space for failure is essential for organisational success. Embracing failure is a strategic move that creates high-performing teams, allowing organisations to stay competitive and relevant. It's a path to success that HR leaders can confidently guide their teams on.
The Role of Failure in Learning and Innovation
Failure is a natural and inevitable part of life. We are bound to make mistakes, face setbacks, and experience failures at some point in our personal and professional lives. They teach us important lessons, provide us with new perspectives, and push us to adapt and improve. Failure allows us to step out of our comfort zones, take risks, and explore new ideas and approaches.
Similarly, failure plays a critical role in driving learning and innovation within organisations. It encourages employees to think creatively, experiment with different methods, and challenge the status quo.
However, not all failures are good failures. Amy Edmondson's book The Right Kind of Wrong highlights that understanding the three archetypes of failure—basic, complex, and intelligent—is crucial for organisations to harness their potential effectively.
Basic Failures are simple mistakes that can be avoided with better processes. Take, for instance, a typo or an error in data entry. These failures are not beneficial and should be avoided.
Complex Failures occur in complicated systems where multiple factors interact unpredictably. While these failures may not be desirable, they can provide valuable lessons for future improvements.
Intelligent Failures, however, are the most valuable—they happen when we venture into new territory and learn something useful despite the setback. These failures are not the result of carelessness or incompetence but rather a consequence of pushing boundaries and trying new things.
To embrace these intelligent behaviours, we need to change our mindset and culture. This shift requires reducing fear and encouraging employees to share mistakes and learn from them. This is where the concept of psychological safety comes into play.
Understanding Psychological Safety
Psychological safety is the belief that one can speak one's mind and express ideas and opinions without fear of negative consequences. It is a sense of trust and openness within a team or organisation that allows individuals to take risks, ask questions, and make mistakes without feeling embarrassed or punished.
Research, including Google's Project Aristotle, shows that teams with high psychological safety perform better, experience lower burnout, and are more innovative. A study in the Journal of Organizational Behavior also found that companies prioritising psychological safety experienced higher creativity levels and brought innovative products to market faster.
Take, for instance, companies like Pixar and Google. Would they have been able to create groundbreaking products like Toy Story or Google Maps if their employees were afraid to speak up and take risks?
Project Aristotle and Psychological Safety
No, they foster an environment where employees feel safe to voice ideas, experiment with new products, and make mistakes without judgment. In turn, this creates a culture of learning, growth, and innovation.
Overcoming Barriers to Implementing Psychological Safety
Despite the tangible benefits of psychological safety on teams and an organisation's bottom line, in her book, Amy Edmondson raises three common misconceptions and barriers still prevent its effective implementation.
One of the biggest barriers to implementing psychological safety is the false dichotomy regarding performance standards. Many believe that creating a safe space for employees to make mistakes will lower performance standards. However, this could not be further from the truth.
In fact, high psychological safety can improve performance and create a culture of continuous improvement. When individuals feel comfortable admitting their mistakes, they are more likely to learn from them and avoid repeating them in the future.
Another barrier is resistance to change. Overcoming resistance from individuals and teams accustomed to a blame culture requires strategic interventions. Change is often met with scepticism, especially in environments where admitting mistakes has historically led to negative repercussions. A gradual approach, with visible support from leadership and open dialogue, can help break down these barriers.
Then, of course, is the fear of failure. While failure is necessary for learning and growth, it can still be a scary prospect for individuals. Organisations need to highlight and celebrate examples where failure has led to significant learning and subsequent success. By showcasing these examples, employees can see failure as a stepping stone rather than a career-ending event.
Strategies to Embed Psychological Safety and Encourage Failure
This brings us to the penultimate question—how do we create a culture of psychological safety and failure in our organisations?
As an HR Leader, you can adopt several strategies to promote psychological safety and embrace failure as a tool for learning and innovation. However, before you implement anything, understanding the current state of your organisation's culture is crucial.
You could conduct surveys to measure psychological safety with questions such as:
"If you make a mistake on this team, it is not held against you,"
"Members of this team are able to bring up problems and tough issues,"
"People on this team sometimes accept others for being different,"
"It is safe to take a risk on this team."
You could also use text and voice analysis tools to identify and monitor the language used in team meetings, emails, and messages. Looking for keywords such as "failure," "mistake," and "blame" can provide insight into areas where psychological safety is lacking. It can also help identify patterns and address any issues or concerns.
Once you have a good understanding of the current state, here are some strategies you could implement to promote psychological safety and encourage failure:
Leadership Commitment
Leadership commitment is essential for fostering psychological safety. As such, leaders must demonstrate behaviours that promote psychological safety, such as admitting their own mistakes and encouraging open dialogue - setting a powerful example for the rest of the organisation.
Clear communication about the importance of psychological safety and its role in achieving organisational goals is also crucial. Therefore, regularly reinforcing the message that experimentation and learning from failure are valued and essential for growth and success is vital.
Structured Reflection and Learning
Encouraging structured reflection and learning is another way to promote psychological safety. This could include regular team meetings, where individuals can share their thoughts and ideas without fear of judgment.
These reviews should be conducted in a non-punitive manner, focusing on learning and improvement rather than assigning blame. Another key strategy is implementing blameless reporting systems, where employees can report errors without fear of blame or punishment. This could be anonymous reporting channels or open-door policies where employees can discuss concerns with their leaders.
Creating Supportive Teams
Creating supportive teams involves establishing explicit norms and ground rules to promote open communication and honesty within teams. This could include establishing guidelines for giving and receiving feedback, encouraging active listening, and fostering a safe space for dissenting opinions. But remember to regularly revisit and adjust these norms to ensure they remain relevant and effective.
Providing psychological safety training can also help teams recognise and build psychological safety within themselves. This can include training on communication, active listening, and emotional intelligence to help employees and business leaders better understand their own emotions and the emotions of others.
Encouraging a Growth Mindset
This is all about framing failures as opportunities for growth and learning rather than as negative outcomes, encouraging employees to view challenges as chances to develop new skills and knowledge.
Recognising and celebrating failures that lead to valuable lessons and innovation is key. By highlighting "intelligent failures," organisations can reinforce the message that failure is a necessary part of the innovation process. Encouraging continuous improvement and experimentation by setting incremental goals and celebrating small wins will also help build momentum and maintain a focus on progress.
Ensuring Accountability
Promoting psychological safety and embracing failure should not mean a lack of accountability. Employees should understand that while failure is acceptable, repeated mistakes without learning or improvement are not. Therefore, creating a culture of accountability is essential, where individuals take ownership of their actions and learn from mistakes. This involves providing constructive feedback and support for improvement rather than punishment.
It is also essential for leaders to model accountability and take responsibility for their own mistakes, creating a culture where individuals feel safe admitting errors and seeking help when needed.
Foster Psychological Safety & Embrace Failure for Growth
Promoting psychological safety and embracing failure is not easy, but it is essential for building a resilient and innovative organisation. By understanding the current state of your organisation's culture and implementing these strategies, you can create an environment where individuals feel safe to take risks, learn from failures, and ultimately drive growth and success.
As an HR Leader, it is your role to champion this cultural shift and foster a workplace where everyone feels valued, included, and empowered to contribute their best work. By focusing on psychological safety and embracing failure, you can create a workplace culture that promotes continuous learning, growth, and innovation.
Download our Insight222 Research and Discover the Five Trends Shaping People Analytics!
Download for our Insight222 research “Building the People Analytics Ecosystem: Operating Model v2.0” understanding why trends are crucial for success.
People analytics is moving at an accelerated pace, understanding the latest trends is crucial for staying ahead. Our latest Insight222 report highlights the key trends that are impacting people analytics.
Understanding these trends is vital for organisations aiming to leverage people analytics for strategic advantage. To explore these trends in detail and learn how your organisation can harness their power, download the full Insight222 report “Building the People Analytics Ecosystem: Operating Model v2.0” for FREE today!